HOA dispute lawyer Orlando, FL

Can I Sue My HOA For Mismanagement?

Posted on

Understanding Your Statutory Protections As A Florida Homeowner

At Perez Mayoral, P.A., we frequently hear from frustrated homeowners dealing with HOA boards that mismanage their communities. Whether it’s financial irregularities, poor maintenance of common areas, or arbitrary decision-making, HOA mismanagement can significantly impact your property value and quality of life. If you have specific questions about your situation, please contact our team at www.pmlawfla.com, call us at 1-800-777-1305, or email [email protected] for personalized legal advice.

What Constitutes HOA Mismanagement?

Before pursuing legal action, it’s important to understand what legally qualifies as mismanagement:

  1. Financial Mismanagement: Improper handling of association funds, failure to maintain adequate reserves, unauthorized spending, or failure to properly account for expenditures.
  2. Breach of Fiduciary Duty: HOA board members have a fiduciary duty to act in the best interest of the community.
  3. Failure to Maintain Common Areas: Neglecting to properly maintain community amenities, infrastructure, or other common elements.
  4. Violation of Governing Documents: Operating in ways that contradict the association’s declaration, bylaws, or rules and regulations.
  5. Failure to Follow Proper Procedures: Making decisions without proper notice, meetings, or votes as required by Florida law.

Comprehensive Statutory Protections Under Florida Law

Condominium Associations (Chapter 718)

Chapter 718 of the Florida Statutes, known as the Condominium Act, provides extensive protections for condominium owners:

Financial Accountability

  • Detailed Financial Reporting (718.111(13)): Condominiums must prepare annual financial statements based on association revenue, with specific requirements for audits, reviews, or compiled financial statements.
  • Budget Requirements (718.112(2)(f)): Mandatory budget adoption procedures with detailed requirements for reserve accounts.
  • Assessment Collection Limitations (718.116): Specific procedures for collecting assessments with limitations on interest and late fees.

Operational Transparency

  • Records Access (718.111(12)): Extensive rights to inspect official records within 10 working days of a written request.
  • Meeting Requirements (718.112(2)(c)): Strict notice requirements for board and membership meetings, with specific posting timelines.
  • Voting Rights (718.112(2)(d)): Detailed procedures for elections and voting, including the right to use proxies and electronic voting.

Board Accountability

  • Term Limits (718.112(2)(d)): Board members cannot serve more than eight consecutive years unless approved by two-thirds of voters.
  • Conflict of Interest Provisions (718.111(1)(a)): Directors must disclose and may not vote on matters that financially benefit themselves or relatives.
  • Certification Requirements (718.112(2)(d)4.b.): Board members must certify that they have read the governing documents or complete an educational course.

Enforcement Mechanisms

  • Division Authority (718.501): The Division of Florida Condominiums, Timeshares, and Mobile Homes has broad investigative and enforcement powers.
  • Civil Penalties (718.501(1)(d)): The Division can impose civil penalties for violations of statute or rules.
  • Receivership (718.1124): Courts may appoint a receiver in cases of substantial failure to maintain the common elements or provide services.
  • Enforcement Actions (718.303): This critical section provides specific remedies:
    • Actions for non-compliance may be brought by the association or unit owners against:
      • The association
      • A unit owner
      • Directors designated by the developer (for actions before unit owner control)
      • Any director who willfully and knowingly fails to comply with statutory provisions
      • Any tenant leasing a unit or other invitee occupying a unit
    • The prevailing party is entitled to recover reasonable attorney fees
    • A unit owner who prevails against the association may recover additional amounts determined by the court to reimburse the unit owner for their share of assessments levied by the association to fund its litigation expenses
    • These remedies do not exclude other remedies provided by law
    • Actions under this subsection are not considered actions for specific performance

Homeowners Associations (Chapter 720)

Chapter 720 provides different but substantial protections for homeowners in planned communities:

Financial Protections

  • Financial Reporting (720.303(7)): Annual financial reporting requirements based on association revenue.
  • Reserve Funds (720.303(6)): Requirements for handling reserve accounts if established.
  • Assessment Limitations (720.308): Restrictions on certain types of assessments and spending.

Operational Transparency

  • Records Access (720.303(5)): Right to inspect association records with specific procedures and timelines.
  • Meeting Requirements (720.303(2)): Requirements for notices and conduct of board and member meetings.
  • Voting Rights (720.306): Specific procedures for elections and votes on association matters.

Board Accountability

  • Director Obligations (720.303(1)): Directors must discharge duties in good faith, with the care of an ordinarily prudent person.
  • Removal Rights (720.303(10)): Process for recall of board members who fail to perform their duties.
  • Transition Requirements (720.307): Specific requirements for developer transition of control to homeowners.

Enforcement Options

  • Statutory Damages (720.305): Provisions for damages and attorney fees for prevailing parties in certain disputes.
  • Covenant Enforcement (720.305(1)): Associations and members can take legal action to enforce governing documents.

Mandatory Dispute Resolution Requirements

Arbitration Requirements Under 718.1255

For condominium associations, Florida Statute 718.1255 establishes a mandatory non-binding arbitration process for many disputes before litigation can be pursued:

  • Important Notice: Certain disputes between condominium associations and unit owners must go through arbitration before a lawsuit can be filed. Florida Statute 718.1255 contains specific requirements and procedures that must be carefully followed.
  • Types of Disputes: The statute specifies which types of disputes require arbitration and which are exempt. Generally, disputes involving the authority of the board, the rights of owners, and enforcement of governing documents require arbitration.
  • Procedural Complexity: The arbitration process involves specific filing requirements, deadlines, and procedures that can be technically complex and challenging to navigate without legal assistance.
  • Consulting an Attorney: Due to the technical nature of these requirements and potential consequences of non-compliance, condominium owners who are involved in or anticipating a dispute should consult with an attorney experienced in condominium law as early as possible.

Mediation Requirements Under 720.311

For homeowners associations, Florida Statute 720.311 establishes mandatory pre-suit mediation for most disputes:

  • Mandatory Pre-Suit Mediation: Most disputes between a homeowners association and an owner must go through pre-suit mediation before a lawsuit can be filed. This is a strict requirement under Florida Statute 720.311.
  • Compliance is Critical: The statute contains specific requirements for initiating and responding to mediation demands. Failure to properly comply with these requirements can result in significant penalties, including the dismissal of subsequent litigation or the imposition of attorney’s fees and costs.
  • Response Deadlines: When served with a mediation demand under this statute, there are strict deadlines for response. Ignoring a properly served mediation demand can have serious legal consequences.
  • Seek Legal Counsel: If you receive a mediation demand under 720.311, or if you are considering sending one, it is strongly recommended that you consult with an attorney immediately. The technical requirements of the statute must be strictly followed, and the consequences of non-compliance can be severe.

Steps to Take Before Filing a Lawsuit

Before rushing to court, consider these important preliminary steps:

  1. Document Everything: Keep detailed records of all instances of mismanagement, including dates, descriptions, photographs, and how they’ve affected you.
  2. Review Governing Documents: Understand the specific obligations and powers of your HOA as defined in your community’s declaration, bylaws, and rules.
  3. Communicate Formally: Submit written complaints to the board following procedures in your governing documents. Use certified mail to create a paper trail.
  4. Prepare for Mandatory Dispute Resolution:
    • For condominiums, be aware that certain disputes require arbitration under 718.1255
    • For HOAs, understand that most disputes require pre-suit mediation under 720.311
    • Gather all necessary documentation to support your position
    • Consult with an attorney experienced in association law before initiating or responding to dispute resolution proceedings
  5. Statute of Limitations Awareness: Be mindful that certain claims have time limitations, typically ranging from one to five years depending on the type of claim.

Legal Claims in HOA Mismanagement Lawsuits

When suing for HOA mismanagement, your attorney may pursue several legal theories:

  1. Breach of Fiduciary Duty: Board members must act in the best interest of all homeowners.
  2. Breach of Contract: The HOA’s governing documents constitute a contract.
  3. Negligence: The board has a duty to exercise reasonable care in managing the association.
  4. Statutory Violations: Failure to comply with specific requirements of Florida Statutes.

Potential Remedies

If your lawsuit is successful, you may be entitled to:

  • Injunctive Relief: Court orders requiring the HOA to take specific actions.
  • Monetary Damages: Compensation for financial harm caused by mismanagement.
  • Appointment of a Receiver: In extreme cases, courts may appoint a neutral third party.
  • Attorney’s Fees: The prevailing party is typically entitled to recover reasonable fees and costs.

Florida law provides homeowners with substantial statutory protections against HOA mismanagement, but navigating the mandatory dispute resolution processes can be complex. The specific requirements of arbitration under 718.1255 for condominiums and mediation under 720.311 for homeowners associations must be strictly followed before proceeding to court.

While these dispute resolution requirements may seem burdensome, they often provide an opportunity to resolve disputes more quickly and economically than litigation. When serious mismanagement persists and threatens your property values or quality of life, understanding these statutory protections and procedures is essential.

At Perez Mayoral, P.A., we understand the complexities of HOA disputes and can help you navigate your options, from mandatory pre-suit mediation or arbitration through litigation if necessary. For assistance with your specific situation, please visit our website at www.pmlawfla.com, call us at 1-800-777-1305, or email us at [email protected].

DISCLAIMER

This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is created by reading or responding to this content. Laws change frequently, and this information may not reflect current legal developments.

Every case is unique. Past results do not guarantee similar outcomes. Before taking any action based on this information, consult with a qualified Orlando, FL HOA dispute lawyer who can review your specific situation.

Perez Mayoral, P.A. disclaims all liability for actions taken or not taken based on this content. For personalized legal advice, please contact our office at 1-800-777-1305 or [email protected].